The 10 Greatest Casserole Dishes: Easy Cooking

Rate this post

Nothing shouts “home cooking” like a casserole. The modest casserole is a mainstay of American cookery, whether it’s with meat and pasta, vegetables and cheese, or something different. Of course, if you want to get it exactly perfect, you’ll need the correct casserole dish.

It might be difficult to choose the best solution. There are several brands, styles, and varieties available. Where do you even begin? We’ve compiled a list of the top ten greatest casserole dishes to assist you in finding the ideal choice for your requirements.


Important Factors to Consider While Purchasing the Finest Casserole Dishes

As our evaluations above demonstrate, there is something for everyone. Whether you’re serving a big group or preparing a casserole on the weekend for weekday lunches, you’ll discover an economical, handy option that’s ideal for you.

But, you may still have doubts regarding what distinguishes one casserole dish from another. You may be curious in the differences in materials, sizes, use types, and other factors. Our shopping advice below will help you make an educated decision and purchase the correct dish for your requirements.

Related Articles:

  • The Top 12 Chafing Dishes in 2022
  • The Top 10 Roasting Pans for Cooking Chickens, Turkeys, and Other Foods
  • The Top 10 Grill Pans to Purchase in 2022
  • The Top 12 Saucepans in 2022
  • The Top 15 Steak Pans for 2022


The form of your casserole dish matters in a variety of scenarios. Personal preference is unquestionably one of them. One form may appeal to you more than another. A deep, square-shaped casserole dish, for example, may appeal to you more than a long, shallow, rectangular one.

Yet, the form also influences things such as how well the casserole dish fits in your dishwasher, in your cabinets, and so on. If you cook regularly, two longer rectangular dishes may be preferable since they enable you to cook two casseroles at the same time, while just one round or square dish may fit in your oven.


One of the most important factors here is material. You’ll see from the meals we examined that there are a variety of alternatives, each bringing something unique to the table. We’ll go through each one in detail below.

Cast Iron: Cast iron casserole pans have several advantages. They are very sturdy and may last a lifetime with a little care. They also absorb, transfer, and retain heat more effectively than many other materials.

When high-quality enamel is applied, you also receive a nonstick, non-reactive surface that is ideal for cooking practically any sort of cuisine. Yet, there are some drawbacks to consider.

The first of these drawbacks is its sheer size. It’s hefty. If you have weak upper body strength, this may not be the material for you. You should also avoid using metal utensils with enamel-coated cast iron since damaging the enamel might cause rust.

Glass: Glass is the most widely utilized material for casserole dishes for a variety of reasons. It is long-lasting, inexpensive, lightweight, and adaptable.

Glass casserole plates are dishwashing and oven safe, as well as microwave, refrigerator, and freezer safe. It allows you to create and store food in the same container, then reheat it anyway you choose.

Having said that, glass may not be the best material for you. Unlike metal dishes, it can be shattered, and the fragments may inflict injury. Glass is also not nonstick, and you may not like the fact that the dish is viewable through the top and sides.

Aluminum: We only tested one aluminum casserole dish since, while being lightweight, adaptable, and sturdy, it is not widely used. It may, however, be reactive with specific meals, such as tomatoes and high-acid foods.

Stoneware is a kind of thick, durable pottery. It has excellent heat dispersal and retention properties, and it may be extremely attractive, as seen by the selections in our evaluations. In most cases, stoneware is dishwasher safe, but the finish used will decide whether you can throw it in with the rest of the plates or need to hand wash it.

Nevertheless, stoneware has a few limitations. For example, it may be heavier than glass and metal dishes. Another issue is that it may still be shattered, and the parts will remain sharp.


When purchasing a casserole dish, size is an important factor. Do you want a 913-inch standard pan? Do you need anything bigger? Maybe you need a smaller one? Would a circular dish work better?

Many factors are influenced by size. It’s not just about appearances or how much space it takes up in your pantry. For example, the same amount of components will have various thicknesses in different sized bowls. A 913 pan enables for greater ingredient distribution than a small, circular dish.

What does this imply for your kitchen? The longer a dish must cook, the thicker it is. As a result, depending on the size of the dish, you will need to adjust the cooking time.

Further steps, such as covering the dish at a given point during a longer cook time to avoid burning while still ensuring that it bakes all the way through, may be required.

Count of Dishes

When purchasing casserole dishes, consider purchasing a set. This allows you two to three plates of varying sizes to utilize, increasing your flexibility and helping you save time and money. But, if you don’t foresee using more than one casserole dish at a time, or if you only need one size, purchasing a single dish is OK.

No Lid or Lid?

As you can see from our ratings, many dishes have lids, but others are offered without. You must determine for yourself if a lid is vital to you. Here are some questions to consider and items to consider:

  • Will you be transporting the dish? If so, a cover is essential, especially if you’ll be transporting a hot food and need to keep the heat.
  • Do your dishes need to maintain heat or moisture? If not, you may cover the dish with plastic wrap, but a lid is required.
  • Do you plan to use the dish outside? If this is the case, a cover is necessary to keep flies and other pests out.

Building of a Lid

If you feel that a lid is necessary, you must also consider its structure. There are various things to consider here, including the following:

  • Fit Check that the lid fits snugly. During transportation, a loose lid will move back and forth. Heat and moisture will also be able to escape.
  • Edge To hold the top firmly in place, make sure it has an edge that fits into the dish.
  • Knob The lid should be able to be raised and lowered. Some have handles on the side, while others have them on the top. Some, like cast-iron casserole pans, have stainless steel knobs affixed to the lid’s top. Handle

Please keep in mind that the information above only pertains to solid lids. Some casserole dishes come with flexible covers that are intended for use during travel and to keep pests out of the dish when used outside.

These lids, which are often made of silicone or plastic, are not oven safe. In most situations, they are also not microwave safe.


Versatility is quite important to certain purchasers. You’ll need the correct material for the task if you want to be able to prepare, serve, and keep your meal in a single dish. In general, glass and stoneware are the most adaptable alternatives.

Casserole dishes constructed of these two materials are typically oven safe to a high temperature (often 500 degrees), microwave safe (check the glaze on stoneware), refrigerator safe, and freezer safe.

Having saying that, none of them will have an airtight seal. That is, although they may come with a cover, if you want to remove the possibility of air entering, you must use plastic wrap instead of or in addition to the top.

Dishwasher Friendly

While we all wish it weren’t so, cleaning up is an important aspect of cooking. If you like a quick and easy cleaning, be sure the casserole dish you choose is dishwasher safe. As a general rule, the following are correct:

  • Dishwasher safe cast iron: Plain cast iron is not dishwasher safe. In fact, you should not wash it by hand with soap and water. It should be scraped clean, lubricated, and stored.
  • Dishwasher Safe Enameled Cast Iron: Enameled cast iron is often dishwasher safe (but not always, so check your set first). To avoid discolouration, several manufacturers, including Lodge, advocate handwashing.
  • Glass casserole dishes, like all of the ones we looked at, are typically dishwasher safe.
  • Metal: Aluminum may be dishwasher safe, but this varies greatly from manufacturer to manufacturer, and even from dish to dish, so check the documentation for yours before loading it.
  • Stoneware: Certain stoneware brands are dishwasher safe, while others are not. It all boils down to the dish’s finish. Before placing your dish in the dishwasher, double-check the papers that came with it.

Size and shape of the handle

Another factor to consider with casserole pans is portability. Handles are the most obvious choice here. There are a variety of handle forms and sizes available, and they are not all the same.

Angled: The handles of certain casserole plates are slanted. Although they are fashionable, they may not be the greatest choice for everyone since they make it easier to drop the food.

Flat handles are the greatest option for a firm grip on your casserole dish. The handles should ideally protrude from the side of the dish, wing-like, at each end.

Freeform: Freeform handles are becoming more uncommon, although you can find them on a select models in our evaluations, such as Rachael Ray’s stoneware dish. These dishes have handles, but they are not visible since they are part of an encircling flange or lip of the dish.

Casserole Dishes that are Disposable

Although none were mentioned in our ratings, disposable casserole pans are available. These are single-use solutions made of heavy-duty aluminum foil. Some also have plastic caps to prevent dust and pests out of your food while in transit.

Should you use a throwaway plate? If you and your family seldom or never eat casseroles and the only time you’d need one is for a special occasion like a family holiday meal or a workplace party, it could be worth considering.

Disposable dishes, on the other hand, are not the best solution for a family that cooks all year. You’ll wind up paying significantly more on disposable pans than you would on a single, high-quality, permanent choice over time.

Top 10 Casserole Recipes

Product Name Grade
Lodge 3.6 Quart Enamel Cast Iron Casserole Dish with Lid A+
AmazonBasics Enamel Cast Iron Covered Casserole Skillet A
Bruntmor Enameled Cast Iron Shallow Casserole Braiser Pan B+
Libbey Baker’s Basics Glass Oval Casserole Baking Dish A-
Libbey Baker’s Basics 3-Piece Glass Casserole Baking Dish Set B+
Rachael Ray Cucina Casserole Dish Set with Lid B+
Rachael Ray Cucina Non-stick Dish/Casserole Pan with Lid A
Anchor Hocking 81932OBL11 Glass Casserole Dish A-
Le Creuset PG07053A-3367 Heritage Stoneware Covered Rectangular Casserole B+
Rachael Ray Glaze Ceramics Dish/Casserole Pan with Lid A-

1. Lodge 3.6-Quart Enable Cast Iron Casserole Dish with Lid

See it on Amazon

Highlighted Characteristics

  • reputable brand
  • Cast iron in enamel
  • 3.6-quart capacity
  • It includes a lid.
  • oven-safe stovetop

Nothing compares to the powers of cast iron when it comes to cooking. But, since cast iron is prone to rusting, you must spend some additional time and effort seasoning it and then maintaining that seasoning. Lodge’s enamel cast iron casserole dish solves all of these issues.

It includes a 3.6-quart casserole dish with a cover, both made of high-quality cast iron. For convenience, the lid is topped with a stainless steel knob. This casserole dish is both versatile and attractive, and it will endure a lifetime.

Since it is oven safe to 500 degrees, you may use it as a conventional casserole dish (including the lid). If required, it is also built for stove-top usage, enabling you to broil, braise, bake, roast, sauté, simmer, or fry anything you desire. While this dish is dishwasher safe, the manufacturer suggests hand cleaning since the enamel may fade if washed in a dishwasher.

2. AmazonBasics Enameled Cast Iron Covered Casserole Skillet

See it on Amazon

Highlighted Features

  • 3.3-quart storage capacity
  • Cast iron enameled with a non-reactive enamel
  • Safe to use in the oven and on the stovetop
  • Warranty period of one year

This compact cast-iron casserole dish is a simple and adaptable baking option. To make things even simpler, it comes with a handy lid with a stainless steel grip. Another useful feature is the side loop-style handles, which make transferring the dish easier.

This casserole dish distributes heat evenly for balanced cooking. It is oven safe up to 400°F (including the lid). Since the enamel finish is non-reactive, it will not interfere with the tastes of your meal. This cast iron casserole dish may be used on any kind of stove, even induction. It is, however, handwash only and should not be placed in the dishwasher. It does, however, come with a one-year guarantee.

3. Bruntmor Enameled Cast Iron Shallow Casserole Braiser Pan

See it on Amazon

Highlighted Elements

  • Great for baking and other forms of cuisine
  • Cast iron of the highest quality
  • 3.8-quart storage capacity
  • Handles in the form of loops
  • Enamel finish that is non-reactive

If you need a bigger capacity cast-iron casserole dish, this 3.8-quart option from Bruntmore may be the solution. It is made of high-quality cast iron, has a non-reactive enamel covering, and performs admirably.

The casserole dish and cover are both oven safe up to 500 degrees. The lid also has a stainless steel knob for ease movement, as do the dish’s loop-style side handles. It may also be used on the stovetop and works with all kinds of cooktops, including induction.

4. Libbey Baker’s Basics Glass Oval Casserole Baking Dish

See it on Amazon

Highlighted Characteristics

  • It’s all glass.
  • It includes a lid.
  • 1.6-quart storage capacity
  • Bake, serve, and keep
  • Dishwasher friendly

This choice from Libbey is one of the most famous casserole dish shapes in existence, with a mid-range size that suits for most kitchens. Its 1.6-quart capacity is ideal for most side dishes, and the top fits snugly to avoid spillage while transferring it.

This casserole dish is constructed of durable, oven-safe glass. It should not, however, be used on the stovetop. It is dishwasher safe as well as microwave, refrigerator, and freezer safe, giving it a great degree of flexibility.

5. Libbey Baker’s Basics 3-Piece Glass Casserole Baking Dish Set

See it on Amazon

Highlighted Features

  • 3 casserole dishes in a set
  • Glass of superior quality
  • Safe to use in the microwave
  • Dishwasher friendly

Glass may not seem to be a revolutionary material, but it is. What else can go in the dishwasher, microwave, oven, freezer, or refrigerator? You’ll also have the tools to meet any need or occasion.

This set includes one 2-quart dish, one 2.7-quart dish, and one 3.4-quart dish. Nevertheless, none of them come with a lid. They are all oven, dishwasher, refrigerator, and freezer safe.

6. Rachael Ray Cucina Casserole Dish Set with Lid

See it on Amazon

Highlighted Elements

  • two casserole pans and one lid
  • Versatile stoneware dishes
  • Oven safe up to 500°F

Choose the Rachael Ray Casserole Dish Set with Cover for rustic appeal and unrivaled performance. It is made of authentic stoneware and has an excellent degree of heat distribution and retention. The accompanying lid complements the set while also providing protection.

This set includes one 1.5-quart dish and one 2-quart circular dish, both of which have delicate ceramic glazing for protection and beauty. The freeform handles are subtle yet functional for shifting the dishes. Each dish may be baked at a temperature of up to 500 degrees Fahrenheit. They are also safe to use in the microwave, refrigerator, and freezer. The plates and the lid are also dishwashing safe.

7. Rachael Ray Cucina Nonstick Dish/Casserole Pan with Lid

See it on Amazon

Highlighted Characteristics

  • Metal riveted handles
  • Produced from aluminum
  • Nonstick coating without PFOA
  • Lifetime limited warranty

Lid for a casserole pan. It has 4.5 quarts of inner capacity and a PFOA-free, nonstick surface to guarantee your food never sticks. The Rachael Ray Cucina Nonstick Dish is ideal for those searching for a bigger casserole dish.

The casserole dish’s body is composed of high-quality cast aluminum that has been treated to prevent oxidation. The handles are firmly riveted in place for long-term durability and a firm grip. This casserole dish is oven safe to 500°F. It can also be used on most stovetops, however it may not work with induction cooktops. For your piece of mind, it also comes with a limited lifetime guarantee.

8. Anchor Hocking 81932OBL11 Glass Casserole Dish

See it on Amazon

Highlighted Features

  • 2 gallon capacity
  • Handles that are easy to grasp
  • The lid is included.
  • Safe to use in the oven, dishwasher, and freezer.

This two-quart glass casserole dish is from Anchor Hocking, one of the most well-known kitchen equipment manufacturers. The distinctive circular form, long handles, and lid with knob are readily identifiable.

Refrigerator safe, allowing you to cook and store in the same container. The glass has been particularly constructed to assist your food bake evenly while also allowing you to see check progress. It is also manufactured in the United States. Dishwasher, microwave, oven, and freezer safe are the body and lid.

9. Le Creuset PG07053A-3367 Heritage Stoneware Covered Rectangular Casserole

See it on Amazon

Highlighted Elements

  • Authentic Le Creuset craftsmanship
  • Body is rectangular with long handles.
  • The lid is included.
  • Oven safe up to 500°F.

Few companies have the reputation for quality, longevity, and performance that Le Creuset has. This rectangular casserole dish is no different. It is as gorgeous and versatile as it is long-lasting and simple to apply. With a four-quart capacity, this casserole dish is one of the biggest on our list and ideal for large families or family gatherings. The cover sits snugly against the body, aiding in heat and moisture retention.

This stoneware casserole dish also resists stains, chipping, and smells and can be rinsed in the dishwasher. While it is oven safe to 500 degrees, the manufacturer does not advocate using it in the microwave.

10. Rachael Ray Glaze Ceramics Dish/Casserole Pan with Lid

See it on Amazon

Highlighted Characteristics

  • square form
  • 2.5-quart capacity deep
  • Stoneware is a long-lasting material.
  • Oven safe up to 500°F.

This square-shaped casserole dish is eye-catching and unique, with 2.5-quarts of capacity and a tight-fitting cover to help keep heat and moisture. The expanded handles make it simple to lift and carry.

The long-lasting stoneware body and lid resist cracking, stains, and smells. For added flexibility, they are dishwasher, refrigerator, and freezer safe. Both are also oven safe up to 500 degrees.

Thermal Shock: What You Should Know

If you spend any time looking for casserole plates, you will come across the phrase thermal shock. What does it imply, and how does it relate to the way you shop for food? Let’s dig a little deeper.

What exactly is it?

Thermal shock is a well-known phenomena that happens when a high-temperature substance comes into touch with something at a significantly lower temperature (or vice versa). For example, cold water in contact with a heated casserole dish.

What is its function?

Thermal stress may produce fractures in a casserole dish or entirely ruin it. When a cold object comes into touch with a warm object, the heated object shrinks. Shrinkage may produce fractures or even breakage of the whole dish.

What Kinds of Materials Are Affected?

Thermal shock has an effect on all materials to some extent. It is, however, more destructive to materials such as glass, ceramic, and stoneware. Significant temperature changes may damage or even break the crystalline structure of these.

What about metallic materials?

Thermal shock affects metal casserole plates, albeit to a much lesser extent. Since metal does not have a crystalline structure, it can endure thermal shock better.

Factors for Serving

Anything you prepare in a casserole dish must be presented. Although this seems to be a simple task, it may be difficult. For example, the serving utensil you use may be detrimental to the nonstick surface of your dish.

What does this imply? Simply simply, if you use a metal serving instrument like a spatula or ladle in a dish with a readily damaged surface, you will scratch it. When a surface is scraped, it starts to deteriorate.

This applies not just to metal plates with nonstick surfaces, but also to enameled casserole pans. The surface is weakened when a scratch occurs. With an aluminum pan, this causes the nonstick coating to degrade and potentially peel. It indicates that the underlying cast iron may be revealed in an enameled dish, which may lead to rust development and subsequently corrosion of the pan itself.

What Can Be Prepared in a Casserole Dish?

Using a casserole dish may seem to be a simple task. Aren’t they for casseroles? But there’s a lot more to it than that.

With a casserole dish, you can prepare practically anything. Other from casseroles, here are a few ideas of what you may prepare in these dishes:

  • Lasagna
  • Moussaka
  • Dishes with polenta
  • Baked chicken alfredo
  • Baked biscuits and gravy
  • Baked chicken and broccoli
  • Frito pie with chicken
  • Baked noodle
  • Pies in the oven
  • Potatoes gratin
  • Baked hash browns
  • Macaroni and cheese baked in the oven
  • Bake the ravioli

Remember, these are just a few possibilities. There are literally dozens of dishes that employ a casserole dish, ranging from nutritional selections to beautiful junk food to comfort your soul.


There is a casserole dish for everyone, whether you want something practical or fashionable, like glass or metal, or desire a big or little dish. We’ve explored 10 of the greatest casserole dishes, what makes them unique, and even offered a handy guide to help you make an educated decision. It’s now time to go out there and prepare something tasty!


What are the best casserole dishes to buy?

Best Overall, according to our selections. … Peugeot Ecru Appolia Rectangular Ceramic Casserole Dish. Best Splurge: Pyrex 3-Quart Quick Grab Baking Pan with Lid. Finest Ceramic. Dansk Kbenstyle White Large Baker. Emile Henry 13 x 9 Big Rectangular Baker.
Aug 1, 2022

What is the most suitable baking dish for cooking a casserole?

Overall winner: Pyrex Basics 3-Quart Glass Baking Dish

The two-inch-high sides are sufficient for the majority of uses, and the handles are just broad enough to be easily gripped with kitchen towels or oven gloves.

What is the oldest known casserole?

The earliest written casserole recipe discovered in 1250 is macaroni and cheese.

What are 5 components of a casserole?

So, what’s on the inside? Let’s discuss about anatomy: A typical supper casserole has a protein, a starch, a vegetable, a sauce (or other binding agent), and cheese.

What is the most popular dish ever?

The most famous meal in the world is most likely Italian pizza. Pizza left Italy’s boundaries a long time ago and is now devoured all over the globe.

What is the most easiest dish to cook?

10 Meals Every Beginning Chef Should Master
Toasted cheese with a fried egg…. Pizza…. Risotto…. Roast chicken…. Spaghetti carbonara…. Apple pie.
Roasted whole fish… Creamy soup.
Additional details…•October 14, 2022

Is it better to bake a casserole in glass or metal?

– however, with the exception of acidic sweets, metal bakes practically everything better than glass. Since it warms up rapidly, it bakes evenly. It also crisps to perfection and browns wonderfully.

Should I use glass or metal casserole?

Is it better to bake in a glass or metal pan? In most cases, I prefer aluminum baking pans for baking since they transfer heat more rapidly and are simpler to wash, store, and care for. In fact, using glass or ceramic baking pans for some recipes, such as brownies or banana bread, might have negative consequences!

What is the safest casserole cookware?

Cast iron, stainless steel, 100% nontoxic ceramic, glass, and enamel-coated cast iron are the safest cookware materials (cast iron with a glass coating). These nonstick and non-toxic cookware are not only clean and environmentally friendly, but they are also entirely safe for our health.

What is a typical American casserole?

A casserole or hot dish is a baked food with three main components in the United States: pieces of meat (such as chicken or ground meat) or fish (such as tuna) or other protein (such as beans or tofu), various chopped or canned vegetables (such as green beans or peas), and a starchy binder (such as flour,…

Write a Reply or Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *