The 5 Best Brown Sugar Substitutes Available

Rate this post

Brown sugar is an essential product to have on hand in the kitchen. It may be used in cooking and baking. It’s even utilized in drinks. It’s a sweetener that can be used for nearly anything. Yet, not everyone is aware of its contents, how it is created, and the replacements that may be used if one is not available.

Let this post to inform you on the facts and advice you need to know about brown sugar. Take a seat, relax, and enjoy the trip.

How is Brown Sugar Formed?

This sugar is fairly similar to conventional white sugar, except it contains molasses. This is how they got their brown hue. Brown sugar may be made in one of two methods. The first occurs when molasses remains in the sugar crystals. This is known as natural brown sugar. In the meantime, producers may manually combine molasses and white sugar. This is typically the commercial brown sugar found in grocery shops.

Some individuals may be surprised to learn that there are many types of brown sugar.

But first and foremost, the color of the sugar is determined by the amount of molasses it contains.

The light brown sugar, which is often used in baking, is the most prevalent. This is the molasses-containing kind. The second ingredient is dark brown sugar.

Why substitute Brown Sugar?

Although though brown sugar is very beneficial, there are occasions when another kind of sugar should be used in a recipe or as a spice. The most obvious reason to seek for a brown sugar alternative is when you really need it but don’t have enough in your kitchen.

There are sugar substitutes that may replace the quantity of brown sugar required to finish your recipes. Another motivation is to alter the flavor of the dish by employing different sweeteners. Several types of sugar may offer food a distinct flavor, so you can experiment and investigate which kind of sugar would benefit your ideal recipe.

Brown sugar replacements are available to everyone who consumes sugar. But, for certain individuals, switching from brown sugar to another sweetener is not only important, but also required. Those with diabetes, for example, must use something different to sweeten their diet. Since the molasses level of brown sugar might alter what they are preparing, some bakers and chefs mix and match sugars to whatever dish they are making.

There are several reasons why you would seek out a brown sugar alternative, which is why we’ve produced a list of the finest options available. Study the details and nutritional worth of each one to choose which one best matches your taste or lifestyle.

Brown Sugar Substitutes

1. White Sugar 

The easiest brown sugar substitution is to just replace it with pure white sugar. It is produced in the same manner as brown sugar, but the molasses has been removed, resulting in a milder flavor. White sugar is also less moisture-absorbent than brown sugar, so don’t anticipate the same outcomes if your foods are normally quite wet.

This form of sugar has several advantages. It provides energy because it is turned into glucose, enters your circulation, and is absorbed by your body’s cells. People who like going to the gym or being physically active often bring sugar cubes with them in case they need an energy boost.

White sugar is also beneficial to those with high blood pressure and diabetes. A diabetic patient’s blood sugar level might change multiple times, particularly if they follow an intensive diet. In this scenario, sugar will assist in reviving the body.

Individuals who like studying or who have approaching examinations will be relieved to learn that white sugar also improves brain function. You can black out if you lose too much sugar in your body. This does not imply that you must consume sweet meals on a daily basis. Sugar should be used in moderation since too much of it may be harmful to your health.

When using white sugar, use double the quantity of brown sugar that is required. When white sugar is used, the resulting product may have a crisper texture; just be aware of this possibility. This is due to the lack of moisture in white sugar compared to brown sugar. It is the final product obtained after removing all of the moisture from the sugarcane.

White sugar may be used to enhance the taste of savory foods. There are various recipes that employ this ingredient to give the meal a unique flavor. White sugar is used to sweeten baked items as well as drinks, as is customary. It’s one of the simplest sweetening substances to find. It is also the most widely used. Preparing syrups using white sugar is also a breeze.

If you’re preparing homemade candy for the kids, white sugar is a typical element, either as the primary ingredient or as a brown sugar replacement. Just be creative!

This is a fantastic replacement since it is widely available. You may even ask one of your friendly neighbors for some if you run out of sugar and really need one. It’s just something that practically everyone has.

It’s excellent since you don’t have to go out of your way to discover it. That is highly visible as you enter the supermarket shop. You know exactly where to look for it, and it isn’t as pricey as the specialty sugars.

Apart from that, you may use it not only as a replacement, but also in practically any dish that requires sweetening. It’s a versatile component.

2. Muscovado Sugar

Muscovado sugar is manufactured from sugar cane, but it is unprocessed and high in molasses, giving it a deeper hue than brown sugar. It originated in Africa, most specifically on the island of Mauritius, and was then transported to other marketplaces throughout the globe. Because of the molasses content, it has a stronger taste. Some people describe Muscovado sugar as having a flavor similar to caramel with a smokey aftertaste.

The natural or unprocessed form of this sugar distinguishes it from others. Each of its crystals still contains the beneficial molasses that has been extracted from white sugar.

Every teaspoon of muscovado sugar has 15 calories and 4 grams of carbs. Although it may have more nutrients than other forms of sugar, it is absorbed similarly by your body. It has magnesium, potassium, and iron in it. Yet, like with any other sugar, consuming an excessive quantity of this will be bad.

Since it is more costly because it is exotic, this sort of sugar is thought to be a healthier sweetener than other types of sugar. Muscovado is not subjected to excessive processing since it may eliminate the minerals that distinguish it from conventional sugar.

This may be used as a brown sugar alternative when you want your final items to have a strong taste. Also, it is believed to be moister than other sugars or sweeteners, so there is no need to worry about it clumping together.

Muscovado sugar may be used in a variety of recipes. Muscovado carrot cake, Juniper toffees, pear and chocolate puddings, and mojito cake are a few examples. Muscovado may also be used in savory dishes, such as barbecue sauce. That will work just as well as brown sugar.

Since they both include molasses, there isn’t much of a distinction between Muscovado sugar and brown sugar. The first is more costly, which may be a disadvantage, but if you are concerned about the vitamin and mineral content of the sugar you use, Muscovado is an excellent brown sugar alternative for your recipes.

But, since this kind of sugar has a stronger taste and is moister, you must exercise caution while using it. Check the flavor of what you’re cooking to prevent putting too much in and spoiling your dish. Achieve the proper balance by going slowly and reviewing your combination every now and again.

3. Coconut Sugar

Since it is not manufactured from sugar cane, this sugar differs differently from the others on this list. It is instead created from the palm of a coconut. When the palm is cooked, sugar is created. It has the same number of calories as white sugars, but it includes less fructose. Nonetheless, the hue is the same as brown sugar, making it an excellent alternative. You won’t have to worry about having a lighter shade since the hues are close.

If you’re wondering what minerals you’ll obtain from coconut sugar, here are a few examples:

  • Zinc
  • Calcium
  • Potassium
  • Iron

Apart from its mineral composition, coconut sugar is thought to have a lower glycemic index than other forms of sugar.

If you’re not familiar with the glycemic index, it’s a measurement of how much sugar different foods increase in your blood. Also, coconut sugar scored lower than table sugar. It simply results in a somewhat smaller rise in blood sugar. One of the reasons why some people choose coconut sugar is because of this.

Moreover, coconut sugar includes inulin, a fiber that delays the absorption of glucose. Diabetic people may swap this for brown sugar in their diet. Nonetheless, since it still includes calories, it should be ingested in the same manner as ordinary white sugar. Patients should also be cautious while purchasing one since some coconut sugar products on the market are blended with table sugar. Always check the product label to prevent being duped and purchasing the incorrect one.

There is little question that coconut sugar is an excellent substitute for brown sugar, particularly for those seeking a more nutritional kind of sugar in their recipes. Since it has almost the same properties as brown sugar, it will also provide the output or texture that you anticipate.

Consumers should keep in mind, however, that sugar is sugar. It still has calories and should not be ingested in huge quantities. Just because it seems to be more healthy than table sugar does not imply you may consume too much of it. Be mindful of your sugar consumption, particularly if you have a medical condition.

4. Maple Sugar

You may also utilize maple sugar as an alternative. This is accomplished by the use of maple syrup. This replacement has a distinct maple flavor in addition to its caramel sweetness. It is often used in the preparation of oats or porridge. Yet, it is also used as a brown sugar alternative in pies and pastries.

The taste is what distinguishes maple sugar from brown sugar. Maple sugar may include a touch of cinnamon, vanilla, or even hazelnut. This simply adds to the uniqueness of this alternative.

If you wish to use it in a recipe, keep in mind that it has the same color as light brown sugar, so if you use it as a substitute for dark brown sugar, expect your meal to be lighter in color. Brown sugar is also moister, so if you want this option to have the similar impact, try adding 1-2 teaspoons of maple syrup.

Curiously, brown sugar may be used to replace for maple sugar, but you may need to use more to obtain the same degree of sweetness. But, when it comes to mineral richness, maple sugar triumphs. Calcium, magnesium, and antioxidants are found in maple sugar.

5. Honey

Honey is an obvious substitution for brown sugar or any other kind of sweetness. It is a natural sweetener that is widely available. In fact, many individuals prefer honey over sugar. This is due to the health advantages that this bee product provides.

To begin with, honey includes minerals, enzymes, B vitamins, vitamin C, antioxidants, and amino acids. What makes honey even more appealing is that it is believed to have anti-inflammatory qualities. It also contains antibacterial qualities that may aid in the killing of microorganisms.

You may be itching to try this brown sugar alternative by now. Nevertheless, before you start purchasing jars of honey, you need first understand the regulations for using it as a sugar substitute. Here are a few examples:

  • Since honey is liquid, lower the amount of liquid components in the recipe as well. The usual guideline is to remove one cup of other liquid components for every one cup of honey you want to use.
  • In your recipe, use 3 cups of honey for every 1 cup of sugar. Honey has a sweeter flavor than sugar. Use just two
  • Reduce the temperature of your oven since baked items using honey will burn quicker than those containing sugar.

How to Make Brown Sugar on your own?

Do you want to put your DIY abilities to the test in the kitchen by producing your own brown sugar?

It is incredibly simple to make your own brown sugar. If you don’t want to experiment with any of the brown sugar replacements listed above, you may just produce your own brown sugar.

The first step is to combine molasses and granulated sugar. You may use your mixer to ensure that everything is well combined. Nevertheless, if you don’t have one, you can simply use a fork.

1 spoonful of molasses equals 1 cup of granulated sugar. The mixing procedure is not for the impatient since it takes time for the components to combine together. Just keep mixing until it resembles the brown sugar seen on grocery store shelves.

The advantage of manufacturing your own sugar is that you know precisely how much you’ll need for each dish. This means you won’t have to worry about stockpiling brown sugar. Just make sure you prepare the correct quantity, which is simply enough for your recipe. It might be difficult to keep this kind of sugar soft in storage.

Let’s Sum It Up!

Brown sugar is a popular sweetener nowadays. It may be used in savory recipes, sauces, and even baking. It has a richer taste than table sugar and a moister texture. Brown sugar, on the other hand, is not for everyone.

There are various reasons why you would want to learn about brown sugar replacements, one of which is if you don’t have any on hand. It’s a popular ingredient, but what if you run out? To avoid the inconvenience of going out to acquire one, you must be inventive and utilize these replacements.

Another argument is that it is good for your health. Individuals who are concerned about their health may wish to experiment with different types of sweeteners. While brown sugar is known as natural brown sugar, there are superior sweetening substances available, such as honey.

Honey has anti-inflammatory effects, which is beneficial to allergy sufferers. Coconut sugar is also an excellent choice since it provides nutrients that ordinary sugar lacks. Sugar in moderation is beneficial to your health. It genuinely provides you with the energy you need and aids in the proper functioning of your brain.

It is crucial to remember, however, that all of these alternatives are still essentially sugar. They ate a lot of calories, which is harmful for your health if you consume too many of them. It has the potential to promote obesity and diabetes. Muscovado sugar and Maple sugar are excellent taste alternatives. These will provide other tastes to your dish, which may be intriguing. You may experiment with a variety of recipes. It will be an enjoyable learning experience for both you and your taste senses.

However, if you want the simplest option, or if you don’t have the time to experiment with your ingredients, you may just grab for standard table sugar and use it to sweeten your cuisine. If you have molasses on hand, you can simply produce your own brown sugar by combining it with granulated sugar and ensuring that it blends smoothly. It should have the consistency of brown sugar.

Ultimately, each alternative has distinct traits and characteristics that you should be aware of. You may need to do more study on them, but picking the ideal one is dependent on your priorities and the person who will consume your meal. If you’re preparing for someone who is particular about the nutritional content of his or her meals, the information we’ve unearthed regarding each brown sugar replacement will come in handy.

It doesn’t really matter what dishes you can make with them as long as you’re prepared to explore in the kitchen. And, of course, understand the regulations. Using honey instead of brown sugar, for example, will need a reduction in the quantity of liquid components. These fundamental guidelines are critical, so remember them at all times.

Another thing to keep in mind is not to get overwhelmed by the nutritional and mineral richness of sugar replacements. In the end, they are still sugar, and you must exercise caution while consuming sweet foods.


What is the best sugar free substitute for brown sugar?

Golden Monkfruit is the best sugar-free brown sugar substitute. If I don’t want to add carbohydrates to a meal, a little golden monkfruit will be the closest equivalent to brown sugar. Another sugar-free alternative is granular white stevia.
Molasses and Stevia.

Is there a sugar substitute that tastes like brown sugar?

Sukrin Gold is a sugar substitute that has the scent, sweetness, taste, and texture of brown sugar!

What brown sugar substitute has no aftertaste?

Sukrin Gold retains its sweetness even at high heats and caramelizes like conventional brown sugar! Some sugar alternatives do not have a “cooling” aftertaste.

What is the healthiest brown sugar substitute?

Coconut nectar

Coconut sugar is manufactured from coconut tree sap. Although though its nutritional profile is quite similar to brown sugar, it is often touted as a healthier sugar alternative ( 2 , 3 ). You may simply replace coconut sugar with brown sugar in a 1:1 ratio.

What is the best substitute brown sugar for diabetics?

Sugar made from dates.

It adds fiber and minerals to your dishes since it is made from whole fruit. Dates are an excellent brown sugar alternative because they retain some of the moisture from their fruit form.

What tastes like sugar but is healthy?

Sugar substitutes include dates, fruit purées, yacon syrup, honey, and maple syrup. While these sweeteners may have less health advantages than refined sweeteners, they should be taken cautiously.

What tastes like sugar but is not sugar?

erythritol, like the sugar alcohols xylitol and inulin, has a sweet flavor similar to table sugar (sucrose), but without the harsh aftertaste seen in other sugar replacements such as saccharin, sucralose (Splenda), and aspartame (NutraSweet).

What non sugar tastes most like sugar?

Taste of Erythritol

Most individuals compare erythritol to sugar and believe the two are identical. It even caramelizes in the same way that sugar does.

What can I replace brown sugar with in cookies?

If you have any of the following pantry goods, you may make an appropriate alternative for brown sugar: maple syrup, agave nectar, honey, brown rice syrup, or date syrup. Mix the liquid sweetener and white sugar in the same proportion as molasses; 1-2 Tbsp for every 1 cup white sugar.

Is there a healthier brown sugar?

Alternatives that are healthier

Stevia is a sugar substitute for those who are worried about their blood sugar levels. It is derived from a plant and is available as packets or drops. According to experts, it is superior than actual sugar for persons with diabetes or prediabetes.

Write a Reply or Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *